Want to enhance your church’s media program, however don’t know the place to start out? Thinking about subscribing to a church media web site, however undecided which one is greatest to your church? Well, just lately I made a submit the place I discussed some very temporary variations between CreationSwap, ShareFaith and Graceway Media. I made a decision that I might perform some research and offer you an in-depth evaluation between all three. While this ShareFaith vs. Graceway Media, I additionally needed to say the advantages of CreationSwap. It’s not one thing you’ll essentially be a part of, whereas the opposite two require a membership charge, which is why we’re specializing in that. This might be a very unbiased method as I’ve solely just lately been uncovered to all three. I haven’t developed any loyalty to any of them, however I’ve used materials from every of them. We will take a look at components comparable to: value, design high quality, customization and options. My aim is to save lots of you the time of doing the analysis, however nonetheless be capable of make an clever choice about what’s proper to your church.
We’ll begin with CreationSwap. I’ll analyze each individually and examine them ultimately. This is their said aim: “Search for royalty-free stock photos, church bulletins, sermon art, logos and more that are shared or sold for free by Christian artists around the world. Also visit our network to connect with artists, view portfolios or to post vacancies for free.”
Cost
The greatest query on everybody’s thoughts is: how a lot is that this going to value me? CreationSwap is the one one in every of these three media corporations that free to obtain. They additionally embody many designs that it’s a must to purchase if you wish to use them. All printed supplies, together with postcards, bulletins, banners and invites are topic to fee in some kind. The prices rely upon the merchandise you buy. They supply a free “membership” though the whole lot is accessible whether or not you join or not.
Design high quality
The second greatest query you in all probability wish to know apart from value is, how good are their supplies? Due to the character of the web site, high quality is hit or miss. Designers can create their very own issues and add them to be used. You may discover some actually nice designs, after which once more, you won’t see a lot that you just like. I might test this web site no less than as soon as per week to see what new designs have come alongside and see if something is likely to be of use to you.
customization
After you’ve chosen a design, you in all probability wish to understand how straightforward it’s to customise it to your church? If you’re useful with Photoshop, some downloads include PSD information that permit enhancing. Others solely present JPG picture information making it not possible to edit and adapt textual content to your church until you’ve gotten superior photograph enhancing abilities.
Functions
• Free downloads
• Print Network
• Community dialogue and weblog posts
• Criticism of design ideas
• Ability to promote your artworks
One of essentially the most invaluable instruments for a designer, apart from the downloads themselves, are the critiques of designs. Even for those who don’t submit your individual designs to get suggestions, you’ll be able to see what some designers have made and what others are saying about it. this gives invaluable insights to enhance your designs for optimum effectiveness.
ShareFaith’s “About” assertion is a little bit too lengthy to submit right here, however its essence is discovered on the outset: “To provide the best solutions in Church digital media, our goal is to partner with Churches and ministries, providing technology solutions and communication tools that will enable them to communicate the gospel more effectively.” To be taught extra about them, go to their About web page.
Cost
Their common worth is $149 per yr, based on their be a part of web page, however proper now they’ve a particular supply of 15% for those who be a part of inside a sure time. This signifies that on the time of writing, the worth to affix is $126.65 per yr. They don’t supply free materials frequently, however they do supply a 10-day free trial. The limitations of that free trial are said on their web site. You can obtain an infinite variety of information throughout your trial interval, however there is just one media loop for sermons and web sites are solely accessible to members.
Design high quality
As a designer, my private opinion of ShareFaith is that their design work is common or barely above common. Some look good, others appear too busy. A missionary good friend of mine designed a poster based mostly on one in every of ShareFaith’s wallpapers after which requested me to spice it up a bit. I ended up throwing the entire thing away and ranging from scratch by shopping for a inventory photograph and creating the whole lot in Photoshop.
customization
This is a giant plus for ShareFaith. Open one in every of their Powerpoint information and also you’ll see what number of totally different variations of clean slide backgrounds they’ve accessible so that you can use, in addition to some totally different ones in service announcement information. You can obtain the Powerpoint itself, or a ZIP file to get the uncooked JPGs and edit them your self.
Functions
• Sermon Powerpoints
• Videos and media clips
• Website Templates
• Bulletin
• Tips & Ideas
• Blog
• And extra…
ShareFaith is the one place the place you could find the whole lot you want to your church. They even present a comparability chart on their web site with Graceway Media. However, the one factor this chart doesn’t speak about is Design Quality, Graceway Media’s greatest asset.
Graceway’s historical past is: “Graceway Media started in 2006 as PowerPoint sermons, with sermon titles and designs. Its purpose was to help pastors present their sermons, giving them quality designs and a selection to choose from.” Since then, our ardour for serving to church buildings preach, educate, and current the gospel has gone past preaching to incorporate designs for worship, particular ministries, particular occasions, holidays, and extra to assist the church with all features of design wants.”
Cost
The prices for a Graceway Media membership are: $249/yr for Stills or Motion graphics individually and a stunning $399/yr for his or her Total Media package deal. They do supply a free trial membership that offers you entry to 24 of their design types. In addition, Graceway Media is by far the most costly of the group.
Design high quality
This is the place Graceway Media shines. A glimpse of their designs can have you salivating for extra. Each design contains a big sermon title, a Powerpoint slide with the sermon title within the nook, and a clean Powerpoint slide. The shifting pictures are HD high quality and don’t have that low cost look that among the free media loop locations have. My first thought in regards to the worth was steep, however after seeing their pictures I may virtually rationalize shopping for a membership for such nice high quality.
customization
Graceway additionally affords the very best customization system. They offer you the clean slide (as already talked about), PSD information for many who can modify the photographs themselves, and a retitling service for many who can not modify the slides themselves. But as could be anticipated once you take a look at the worth tag, they cost a small quantity for this service. They don’t listing their credit score worth publicly, however supply 10 free credit once they join, boasting a worth of $50 that means you’ll pay $5 per slide.
Functions
• HD pictures
• HD shifting pictures
• Personalization
• Banners
• Blog
Graceway is a bit low on options and limits their work to sermon graphics and worship video loops.
So who wins?
As a complete, Graceway Media seems like a extra private ministry to me. They have posted a photograph of their total crew on their web site that makes faces on the ministry. Since signing up for his or her free trial, I’ve been approached twice asking how I favored it and if I used to be fascinated with signing up for the membership. But I actually can’t communicate for ShareFaith as a result of I personally don’t have an account, though my church does. Let’s begin including up the factors and see who wins.
Cost
CreationSwap is free for essentially the most half, so you need to usually go to this web site searching for what to make use of. If you discover one thing you want that prices some cash, be at liberty to pay for it in order for you, however you’ll pay for every merchandise individually. Out of the 2 membership websites, ShareFaith wins the Cost award.
Design high quality
Graceway Media takes residence this award. I’ve checked out many church media useful resource web sites and GraceWay Media beats all of them. Nothing is sharper or higher designed than the fabric at Graceway.
customization
This is a tie between ShareFaith and Graceway. ShareFaith affords loads of supplies for customizing your individual supplies, however that’s it. Graceway affords a extra superior Retitling service, however it is going to value you each time you need it completed. Therefore, they every get one level.
Functions
ShareFaith simply takes the gold for options. Their personal chart, talked about above, makes that clear. ShareFaith is the full media package deal for the church that has the whole lot you’ll ever want.
conclusions
ShareFaith beats Graceway Media 3 to 2 until you embody Graceway’s kindness within the combine then it’s a 3 to three tie. The laborious fact is that ShareFaith is cheaper and plenty of church buildings want cheaper. They additionally supply extra options, so for the church on a finances, ShareFaith is the one selection even possible. However, in case your church can afford a little bit further, you’ll get significantly better design high quality from Graceway Media. Oh, and don’t neglect that irrespective of who you might be, you need to take a look at CreationSwap for the newest freebies.
Traver Freeman
Warning! Downloading copyrighted materials is against the law, and all of the information listed below are just for academic makes use of. for those who want to use this file on-line it’s a must to purchase a real model. We don’t personal and resell this product, we acquired this from a free supply. Developers/creator/maker made it with problem. We request you to purchase a real model.
